Don't get me started!
As an avid Esbit user, I asked myself the same question on many occasions. It's my perception that people are passionate/fanatical about alcohol stoves.
After all comparisons are made, there are no real advantages of using an alcohol stove. Alcohol costs less, but you can't mail it and it can be tough to find along the trail. Alcohol boils water faster. When comparing 8 minutes to 13 minutes to make dinner, does it really matter? Are you in a rush?
Solid fuel is lighter than canisters, gas or alcohol, you can mail it and it's a complete no brainer to use. You don't even need a stove, 3 tent stakes and a rock work just great.
Ironically, many alcohol stove users will carry a solid fuel tab such as esbit as a backup or emergency fire starter. Go figure.
In the
PCT FAQ I've made an extra effort to warn folks on the dangers of alcohol stoves. Some folks may say that 3 major forest fires by alcohol stoves in 5 years is no reason to be an alarmist. I
strongly disagree.
Using alcohol that disperses, while burning, in windy conditions in a tinderbox like southern/central california is dangerous and irresponsible.
Keep this photo close as a constant reminder if you must carry an alcohol stove.
Whew! Rant over.
-postholer
