Hey Bulldog, Thanks!
I started in Sept 2007 with Longs Peak.
As you mention living in NY made me need to be pretty efficient with my trips out relating to timing, acclimatizing, training, and route planning. The fact that I used 2wd rental cars meant starting from the lower trailheads also, which I didn't mind since after all, I come to the mountains to climb MORE not less!
This made the bigger difference on peaks like Grays/Torreys/Antero/Princeton/Uncompahgre/Blanca Group, which were all 14-17 mile trips each given where you stop with 2wd, with a good +5500-7000ft gain, compared to some 4x4s which can make it up to 11k or 12k! - sort of defeats the purpose of a climb, right??
For Pikes, we did the Crags route, which is approx. 14 miles r/t and +4500ft gain. Evans has a couple of options, I did it climbing first over Spalding then to the summit.
I actually would like to try the Barr Trail next time out.
There are a few that are close like Democrat/Lincoln Group, Belford/Oxford/Missouri, etc. The best ones are long and isolated like The Chicago Basin, Capitol, Snowmass, Holy Cross, etc.
As you mention, so many options!
Next for the Sierra 14ers! Aiming for Shasta in May/June.