So I went to the Used Gear Sale at my local REI and boy did I get a good deal!
I picked up a once used Big Agnes Fly Creek UL2 tent for $200! The reason for the return you ask? Stuff sack was ripped. Set it up in the parking lot before purchase and there were no signs of use, no dirt on the bottom or where the poles would go. Best I can figure is that someone set it up in their living room and ripped the stuff sack while packing it away.
I also got my Fiance a set of once used KEEN Voyageur Mid hiking boots for $30!