What numbers do you think would be more appropriate for a region the size of the North Fork?
25-30 seems reasonable. How can the main trail handle 60 overnights and probably 90% of the 100 available day hiker permits but north fork only gets 10? Doesn't make sense.
I can't tell whether this response is mean spirited or elitist.........
A little of both. I have no problem with people hiring guides. Just the unreasonable quotas.
The guide services are monitored and their usage of the area controlled under the special use authorization system of the national forest and also regulated by the state.
I understand and I think that's why they only give 10 spots per day for the general public. I am sure what ever bureaucracy regulates the guide services gets a good amount of money in licenses and fees. They need to keep the number of available permits low so they can have room for the guide services. It always comes down to money.
What are your sources for the figures of 6, 8, 10, 12 people per group in the North Fork?
First hand experience. A few weeks ago I saw a group of 8 and a group of 6. A few months ago, 2 groups of 8.